Top 10 Weirdest Ben and Jerry’s Flavors

Peanut Butter and Jelly

Prev Next

Another American classic that didn’t quite translate to a tasty ice-cream. As the gravestone says above it managed to “flop in a cone”.  Why is it that something that works so well in a sandwich is just strange in ice-cream? It featured strawberry jelly and peanut butter chunks, but sadly only featured in the Ben & Jerry’s range for a year.